ABSTRACT
Aim:
Plantar fasciitis (PF) is a painful and disabling disease that affects the quality of life and daily activities of patients and it is the most common cause of heel pain in adults. In primary treatment, conservative treatment is suggested and different conservative options are described in the literature. In our study, we evaluated the efficacy of plantar fascia-specific stretching exercises in the treatment of PF.
Methods:
Twenty-nine feet - 21 patients with the mean age of 49.3 years were included in the study. The mean length of follow-up was 19.8 months and the mean length of exercise period was 4.94 months. Non-weight bearing plantar fascia-specific stretching exercise was done twice daily, for 10 times at each session. In addition to exercises, silicone heel pad and nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAID) were added. Visual analog scale (VAS) was used for pain evaluation.
Results:
Full recovery detected in 15 feet in 10 patients (52%) and a decrease in pain was seen in 10 feet in 8 patients (34%). There was no response in 4 feet in 3 patients (14%). There was statistically significant difference between pre-treatment and post-treatment visual analog scale scores (p=0.0001).
Conclusion:
Plantar fascia-specific stretching exercise is an effective treatment option in PF.
Introduction
The plantar fascia is composed of fibrous connective tissue which is important for static structure of the longitudinal arch of the foot. The plantar fascia elongates with increased loads to act as a shock absorber, however, its ability to elongate is limited (1). Maximum elongation is about 4% of the structure and a force of approximately 1000 N is required to cause failure (2).
Plantar fasciitis (PF) is a disabling disease which negatively affects the quality of life and daily activities of patients. PF is the result of repetitive microtrauma at the origin of the medial tuberosity of the calcaneus (3). Thickness of the plantar fascia increases and also degeneration occurs (4,5). PF is the most common cause of heel pain in adults. In the United States, more than 2 million people are affected every year (6,7). In 90% of cases, symptoms relieve in 10 months (8), however, this long period is frustrating for both patients and clinicians (9).
Conservative treatment is the primary treatment choice in PF. Different conservative treatment methods are described, however, no single treatment has been proven to reduce heel pain (10). Plantar fascia-stretching exercises are one of the conservative treatment options suggested in the literature (1,11-13).
In this study, the efficacy of plantar fascia-specific stretching exercises in conservative treatment of PF was evaluated.
Methods
The diagnosis of PF depends on the history and physical examination. In this study, the history of patients included a heel pain with the first step in the morning and which decreases by walking and increases again after standing for a long time. During physical examination, inferior-medial side of the heel was painful by palpation. Patients with bilateral heel pain were evaluated for systemic diseases; if a systemic disease was discovered, the patient was excluded from the study. The patients were evaluated for differential diagnosis of other inferior heel pain causing diseases, such as tarsal tunnel syndrome, L5–S1 radiculopathy, fat pad atrophy, calcaneal stress fracture, tumors or tumor-like lesions. Plain radiography was studied for all patients.
Between the years 2007 and 2008, patients with the complaint of heel pain were examined and 36 patients-52 feet were diagnosed with PF. None of the patients had a history of previous surgery of the heel. All patients were asked to do the non-weight bearing plantar fascia-specific stretching exercises, twice a day, 10 times, for duration of 20 seconds each time (Figure 1, 2). Silicone heel pad use during mobilization was suggested and non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAID) were prescribed, if there was no contraindication to NSAID use. The patients were informed that the exercise should be done regularly for 8 weeks which may be extended for a longer time and were called for follow-up visits every 2 months.
At the last follow-up visit,15 patients-19 feet were excluded from the study due to non-compliance with the exercise program. During the last follow-up, single foot of 4 bilateral PF patients were left out by mistake. Therefore, those 4 feet were also excluded from the study. The study was done with 29 feet-21 patients. Visual analogue scale (VAS) (0 to 10) was used for evaluation of pre-treatment and post-treatment pain complaints. Eighteen patients were female, 3 were male. The mean age was 49.3 years (24-72), the mean length of follow–up was 19.8 months (11–28 months), and the mean period of exercise was 4.94 months (0.25 to 24 months).
Informed consent was obtained from all patients, and the principles outlined in the Declaration of Helsinki were followed during the study.
Statistical Analysis
Statistical analysis was done using NCSS2007 software. For data assessment, definitive statistical methods (mean, standard deviation) were used and the Wilcoxon test for repetitive measures was studied.
Results
The pain resolved in 15 feet in 10 patients (52%). A decrease in pain was detected in 10 feet in 8 patients (34%) and there was no response to treatment in 4 feet in 3 patients (14%) (Table 1).
Post-treatment VAS scores were statistically significantly lower than pre-treatment VAS scores in patients with PF who did plantar fascia-specific stretching exercises (p=0.0001).
Discussion
Primary treatment of PF consists of conservative treatment methods. Surgical treatment options are considered when conservative methods are insufficient. In the literature, it has been recommended that before the decision for surgery is made, conservative treatment should continue for 6 to12 months (14).
Conservative treatment options include shoe inserts (15), NSAIDs (16), night splints (17), stretching exercises (12,13), extracorporeal shockwave therapy (ESWT) (18,19), corticosteroid injection (20), botulinum toxin (botox) injection (21), taping (14), and casting (22).
Surgical intervention may be appropriate for patients who do not response to conservative treatment. However, recent studies have shown that surgery may associate with prolonged recovery time and persistent pain may not dissolve after surgery. Davies et al. (6) reported that less than 50% of patients with chronic heel pain were totally satisfied with the results of the surgical intervention. Therefore, we suggest surgical intervention to be the last resort for he treatment of PF.
ESWT is indicated in PF patients if PF lasts longer than 6 months and in those unresponsive to other conservative treatment modalities (11).
During the development phase of this study, a limited number of studies related to plantar fascia-stretching exercises were found in published literature. Two studies by DiGiovanni et al. (12) published in 2003 and 2006 were significant. While in the first study it was stated that plantar fascia-specific stretching exercises were more efficient than Achilles-stretching exercises, in the second study, they have showed that 58% of patients, who performed plantar fascia-specific stretching exercises, fully recovered, and 94% of patients benefited from stretching exercise treatment. They also pointed out that the length of the exercise period should be extended to 6 months; if no success after 6 months, then other treatment options might be considered (13).
Rompe et al. (23) compared stretching exercises and radial shock-wave therapy in PF patients. They concluded that a program of manual stretching exercises specific to the plantar fascia was superior to repetitive low-energy radial shock wave therapy in the treatment of acute symptoms of proximal plantar fasciopathy, with a satisfaction rate of 65% and 29%, respectively.
In their study, DiGiovanni et al. (12) investigated the preferred management of PF among orthopedic foot and angle surgeons. Eighty-four orthopaedic surgeons completed the survey. At the 4-month visit, 37 respondents (44%) favored initiation of plantar fascia-specific stretching exercises; 62 respondents (74%) preferred surgery or ESWT for patients with ongoing symptoms at 10 months as their next step in the management of PF (24).
Plantar fascia-specific stretching exercises are not efficient in all PF patients. We suppose it depends on different factors (body mass index, thickness of the plantar fascia, etc.) which should be further investigated. The lack of control group decreases the strength of our study.
In conclusion, plantar fascia-specific stretching exercise is an effective conservative treatment option and patients should be informed about the success rate and encouraged to perform regular exercise for PF treatment.
Author Contributions
Ethics Committee Approval: The study were approved by the Local Ethics Committee of Baltalimanı Osteopathic Training and Research Hospital, Informed Consent: Consent form was filled out by all participants, Concept: Devrim Özer, Design: Devrim Özer, Data Collection or Processing: Alper Köksal, Ali Öner, Devrim Özer, Analysis or Interpretation: Devrim Özer, Mehmet Akif Kaygusuz, Literature Search: Devrim Özer, Writing: Devrim Özer, Ali Öner, Peer-review: Internal peer-reviewed. Conflict of Interest: No conflict of interest was declared by the authors, Financial Disclosure: The authors declared that this study has received no financial support.